20 Key Lime Recipes from Popsicles to Pies (2024)

Smaller, juicier and more tart than any of its cousins — that yellow-ish little key lime packs a punch. Consider the tiny citrus treasures a simple way to keep your favorite recipes fresh and light without sacrificing flavor. Key lime tastes great with everything from cookies to cupcakes to co*cktails. Need further proof of its magnificence? Here are 20 refreshing key lime recipes for you to try right now.

1. Key Lime Colada: Kick things off with a twist on the typical colada. This key lime version adds a little extra zip to your favorite co*cktail. (via Cake Then Crumbs)

2. Key Lime Cheesecake Bars: A cuter version of the classic key lime pie, these cheesecake bars are a light and creamy addition to your dinner table. (via BHG)

4. Key Lime Pie Popsicles: How cute are these key lime pie popsicles? The full flavor of a key lime pie that you can hold in your hand. Featuring Greek yogurt, this popsicle recipe is sure to be your favorite summer treat. (via Attune Foods)

5. Key Lime Pound Cake: The classic pound cake gets a chic update with a tangy key lime glaze. (via Confessions of a Cookbook Queen)

6. Coconut Key Lime Pie Martini: Next time you’re tempted to make your usual cosmo, consider this coconut key lime pie martini recipe. The tartness of lime works perfectly with vodka. Included are pineapple juice and cream of coconut with a graham cracker crumb garnish. This tropical treat is sure to be your new go-to martini-glass co*cktail. (via Home Cooking Memories)

7. Creamy Key Lime Chicken Enchiladas: Chicken enchiladas are an easy dish to showcase at your next dinner party. You can prepare them in advance, and they go perfectly with key lime margaritas… (via Pillsbury)

8. Key Lime Margarita: Although the traditional margarita is made with lime juice, this version gets its signature kick from a key lime liquor. With one sip, you’ll feel like you’re lounging on the beach with your feet in the sand. (via JW Illustrations)

11. Key Lime Crush: Every party needs at least one non-alcoholic drink. This crush is the perfect choice for the next time you want to offer something a little more interesting than regular soft drinks. (via Amelia Marie Design)

13. Chocolate-Covered Key Lime Pie: Looking for another popsicle treat? With this recipe, you’ll make the pie first. Once chilled, cut into slices before adding popsicle sticks and dunking the slices into melted chocolate. (via So, How’s It Taste?)

14. Key Lime Angel Food Cake: Light and airy cake is where it’s at. The flavor comes through thanks to a key lime glaze and key lime whipped cream. (via Mother Thyme)

15. Key Lime Whoopie Pies: These cute whoopie pies are so easy to make with the help of a cake mix. They have all the cuteness of a macaron without all the fussiness. (via Cookies and Cups)

16. Key Lime Banana Smoothie: Put some pep in your step first thing in the morning with a key lime banana smoothie. Combining yogurt, lime juice, milk and a banana is an easy way to get a nutritious start to your day. (via Betty Crocker)

17. Key Lime Cream Cake: A gorgeous cream cake may take some time to put together but it’s well worth the effort. Elegantly decorated with whipped cream and graham crackers, this is a cake to be savored. (via Bakerella)

18. Key Lime Bundt Cake: Nothing says homemade baking like the bundt cake. This traditional bundt bursts into the 21st century with bold flavors. (via The 36th Avenue)

19. Key Lime Fruit Dip: Perfect for potlucks, this key lime fruit dip is a yummy addition to any buffet spread. A different spin on the usual yogurt dip, it is perfectly paired with fruit, cookies and graham crackers. (via Jen’s Favorite Cookies)

20. No Bake Key Lime Cheesecake in a Jar: A key lime cheesecake is an obvious crowd-pleaser. Serving it in a jar makes it unforgettable. The fact that this recipe is a no-bake cheesecake makes assembly a snap. (via Life, Love and Sugar)

Which key lime recipe is your fave? Let us know in the comments below!